The free kick that took 13 years to explain

PhysicsFootballTournoi de France · Lyon · 1997

On June 3, 1997, Roberto Carlosstruck a football at 136 km/h from 35 metres, spinning at roughly 14 revolutions per second. The ball flew wide of the wall, appeared to be heading into the stands, and then bent sharply left and hit the inside of the post. The goalkeeper didn't move.

The match was the opening game of the Tournoi de France — a four-team friendly France organised as a rehearsal for the 1998 World Cup. The scoreline was forgotten immediately. Twenty years later, Roberto Carlos told ESPN Brasil: “To be honest, until this day I don't know how I did that.” He added that he never attempted the same kick again, because he knew he could never repeat it.

“He also said: ‘I never tried to kick like that again, because I know I would never have scored.’ The physics confirms this.”

The Magnus effect is named after German physicist Heinrich Magnus, who described it in 1852. But Isaac Newton had noticed it two centuries earlier — watching tennis players at Cambridge in 1670, he observed that a spinning ball curved in the direction of its spin. The mechanism: when a ball spins in flight, one side of the ball moves in the same direction as the surrounding air and one side moves against it. The pressure differential pushes the ball toward the low-pressure side — which is the direction of the spin.

For Roberto Carlos's kick: the ball was struck on its lower-right corner and spun counterclockwise. The ball was pushed down and to the left — directly toward the goal. The effect was small at first. As the ball slowed, the pressure differential became more dominant and the curve tightened. The 35-metre distance was critical: it was long enough for the full spiral trajectory to develop. From 20 metres, the kick would have gone wide.

§

The tolerance window for all the required variables simultaneously is vanishingly small. Too fast, and the ball doesn't curve enough. Too slow, and it hooks too early. Too much spin and it curves wide. Too little and it passes the wall but goes over the goal. The 35-metre distance was not chosen — it was where the free kick was awarded. Everything that made the kick work was the product of a specific physical situation that cannot be recreated through planning.

Isaac Newton first noticed the Magnus effect in 1670. Heinrich Magnus formalized it in 1852. Christophe Clanet and colleagues modelled it as a spiral in 2010. The experiment that made all three of them relevant to the same goal happened on a June evening in Lyon from a free kick that nobody asked Roberto Carlos to take the way he took it. He just kicked it, and physics did the rest.

★★★★★

In short

A goal explained in principle by Newton, formalised by Magnus, and finally modelled as a spiral in 2010. The man who kicked it still doesn't know how he did it.

Sources

Dupeux, Le Goff, Quéré & Clanet — “The spinning ball spiral,” New Journal of Physics, Sept. 2010  ·  Croxford, Best & Duggan — “Roberto Carlos's Impossible Free Kick,” Journal of Physics Special Topics, Univ. of Leicester, Nov. 2017